• Kevin Cleveland

Suitable Seating

California Wage Orders require that employers provide suitable seating for employees under certain circumstances. What has long been unclear is what constitutes suitable seating and under what circumstances must it be provided. Recently in the case of Kilby v. CVS Pharmacy, Inc. the California Supreme Court addressed questions raised by the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeal in answering three vary salient questions:

  1. The “nature of the work” as referred to in the Wage Order refers to an employees’ tasks performed at a given location for which a right to a suitable seat is claimed, rather than some “holistic” consideration of the entire range of the employees’ duties anywhere on the job site anywhere during a complete shift. If the tasks being performed at a given location reasonably permit sitting, and provision of a seat would not interfere with the performance of any other tasks that would may require standing, a seat is called for.

  2. Whether the nature of the work reasonably permits sitting is a question to be determined objectively based on the totality of the circumstances.   An employer’s business judgment and the physical layout of the workplace are relevant but not dispositive factors.   The inquiry focuses on the nature of the work not on the individual employee’s characteristics.

  3. The nature of the work aside, if an employer argues there is no suitable seat available, the burden is on the employer to provide unavailability.

This decision is significant inasmuch as it now requires employers to bear the burden of proving that seats are not available and cannot be used based on specific tasks of an employee throughout their day. The safer approach is to use common sense. If a seat could be used to perform the task or duty then a seat should be provided if the employee wants.

1 view0 comments

Recent Posts

See All

Important Updates for Employers

California Supreme Court Decision Related to Meal and Rest Period Premium Calculations Last week, in Ferra v. Loews Hollywood Hotel, LLC, the California Supreme Court held that meal and rest period pr

New, Approved Changes to Cal/OSHA COVID-19 Guidelines

The third time is the charm for Cal/OSHA which, after previously issuing and then rescinding revised emergency temporary standards regarding COVID-19, finally approved updated COVID-19 Emergency Tempo

Cal/OSHA COVID-19 ETS Update

As some of you may know, the California Occupational Safety & Health Standards Board (“the Board”) was scheduled to vote on proposed revisions to the Cal/OSHA emergency temporary standards (ETS) for C